Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity book, 2008. Einstein s equations given absolute simultaneity pitts, j. The relativity of simultaneity let me begin with a little homily. Pdf absolute simultaneity and rest consistent with. What is simultaneous with an event is what can interact with it. The results can be seen as direct observational expressions of the relativity of simultaneity, if one knows how to read them. One of the most fundamental deductions albert einstein made from the finite speed of light in his theory of special relativity is the relativity of simultaneitybecause light takes a finite time to traverse a distance in space, it is not possible to define simultaneity with respect to a universal clock shared by all observers. The behaviour of measuringrods and clocks in motion. The relativistic velocity transformation and the principle of. This paper is a first presentation of a new approach of physics that we propose to refer as the absolute relativity theory art since it refutes the idea of a preexisting spacetime. On einsteins nonsimultaneity, lengthcontraction and timedilation johan f prins cathodixx, p. As you can guess from the equations for the lorentz transformation, the concept of time becomes a relative concept since we no longer have the simple relation tt. Even prior to the advent of that theory, however, questions had been raised see, e. Box 1537, cresta 2118, gauteng, south aftica non simultaneity of two simultaneous events which occur at different positions within an inertial referenceframe passing by at a speed v.
On einstein s non simultaneity, lengthcontraction and timedilation johan f prins cathodixx, p. With a proper understanding of simultaneity and of other temporal concepts, distant simultaneity in special relativity can be shown to be observerindependent for a significant set of events. The general theory of relativity gr and the dynamic universe du are evaluated in how they explain frequencies of atomic clocks. In that case, einsteins definition would return the familiar absolute simultaneity of classical theory. This site presents a fundamental revision of einstein s special theory of relativity. This work deals with the questions of absolute space and relativity. It includes an algebraic definition of particles, interactions and lagrangians. On the relativity of the conception of distance 11. Student understanding of time in special relativity. Sne ia data with modifications for time contraction. There is no absolute fact to whether a spaceship is moving uniformly or is at rest. Einsteins relativity consistent with absolute simultaneity. One is the relativity postulate, which he accepts in part in virtue of parsimony.
The relativistic velocity transformation and the principle of absolute simultaneity robert j. In this study, it is shown that alt is compatible with current experiments to test lorentz invariance only if the proposed preferred reference frame is locally equivalent to the earthcentered. Absolute simultaneity refers to the concurrence of events in time at different locations in space. In other words, they claim that the theory of relativity as presented by einstein is. Minkowski spacetime and special relativity scarcely anyone who truly understand relativity theory can escape this magic. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity william. Einstein and telecommunications technologies, technology and. There is one more than would suffice for einstein s description of relativity of simultaneity, but this will help our analysis. Moreover he shows that this relation of absolute simultaneity can be exported to any other inertial system s while s 0 is privileged here alone einstein synchronization obtains, it is not experimentally detectable and can be arbitrarily chosen.
Einstein in the previous chapter we saw that tensors are a very good tool for writing covariant equations in 3dimensional euclidean space. Presenting a collection of original essays from a team of international philosophers and physicists, this volume reassesses the contemporary paradigm of the relativistic concept of time. But bob thinks alice has messed up, alice thinks that bob has messed up in terms of his clock synchronization. In this publication the core information about einstein s flawed relativity of simultaneity thought experiment paradigm was specifically extracted from section 12. Absolute distant simultaneity in special relativity.
But its existence enables formulation of a weak relativity principle merely affirming the. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity. It is demonstrated that absolute simultaneity and absolute rest are logically and physically valid, and consistent with the special theory of relativity str kinematics. It can only be said to be at rest relative to another body. In this chapter we will generalize the tensor concept to the framework. Biola university, california, usa western michigan einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity routledge studies in contemporary philosophy kindle edition by william lane craig, william lane. The relativity of simultaneity part 1 the weirdness. No theory based on absolute simultaneity such as so called lorentz. You can download my overview publication in pdf format a sign post to a series of publications revealing the existence of multiple flawed contemporary parad. Einstein, relativity, and absolute simultaneity edited by william lane. Implications of an absolute simultaneity theory for cosmology and. Pdf absolute distant simultaneity in special relativity. But, this dynamics implied the existence of an absolute mo tion. Conventionality of simultaneity stanford encyclopedia of.
The debate about the conventionality of simultaneity is usually carried on within the framework of the special theory of relativity. In nontechnical presentations of the theories of relativity even the best of them the austere pictures of worldlines of clocks are sometimes humanized or anthropomorphized by adding a human observer to the world line to go along with the clock. Relativity of simultaneity wolfram demonstrations project. In this demonstration, light pulses are emitted at the center of a moving train and strike both ends. If one reference frame assigns precisely the same time to two events that are at different points in space, a reference frame that is moving relative to the first will generally assign different. Du and gr predict the frequencies with equal accuracy, but their explanations, the postulates they apply in the. According to the theory of special relativity, it is impossible to say in an absolute sense whether two distinct events occur at the same time if those events are separated in space. But careful analysis shows this cannot be the case if the speed of light is the same in all inertial frames. Most physical theories assume that it is possible to synchronise clocks. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity 2005 marked the centenary of one of the most remarkable publications in the history of science, albert einstein s on the electrodynamics of moving bodies, in which he presented a theory that later came to be known as the special theory of relativity.
Einsteins totally flawed relativity of simultaneity. Lecture 3 and 4 relativity of simultaneity lorentz. Einstein then offers two postulates upon which he will build his new theory. Observation stations a, b and c equally spaced on xaxis in inertial frame in which they are at rest. Sep 20, 2010 lucas the special theory and absolute simultaneity is concerned to rebut the perceived threat to modern theism seemingly posed by special relativity, namely, if time is unreal, the way we live now in the time of our mortal life is of no significance sub specie aeternitatis. In its place, we have the einstein minkowski spacetime. Nov 08, 2007 einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity is an anthology of original essays by an international team of leading philosophers and physicists who have come together to reassess the contemporary paradigm of the relativistic concept of time. We have absolute time t measured from the start all the way down the. The hueristic value of the theory of relativity 15. We argue that the moving observer in a causal variant of einstein s original. On einsteins nonsimultaneity, lengthcontraction and. Is the atheory of time consistent with einsteins rela tivity of simultaneity.
A great deal has changed since 1905 when einstein proposed his special theory of relativity, and this book offers a fresh reassessment of. This principle of relativity was accepted in somewhat simpler form i. Absolute distant simultaneity in special relativity article pdf available in foundations of physics march 2014 with 7 reads how we measure reads. But it was asked here a month ago, and no one answered it. Albert einstein 5 preface december, 1916 the present book is intended, as far as possible, to give an exact insight into the theory of relativity to those readers who, from a general scientific and philosophical point of view. There is no absolute fact as to whether a rod is a foot long or a process lasts for one minute. However, using the derivation of the equation for the relativity of time from the doppler equation, we can perfectly explain the relativity of simultaneity and salvage it for the absolute theory of relativity, while simultaneously snicker, snicker rejecting einstein s theory, the special theory. Continuing to examine the figure we see 4 points with their marks. How to do calculation in relativity of simultaneity physics.
Relativity of simultaneity if we use this method of synchronising clocks, we find that simultaneity is relative, not absolute. Jan 01, 2007 einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity is an anthology of original essays by an international team of leading philosophers and physicists who have come together to reassess the contemporary paradigm of the relativistic concept of time. Alt maintains absolute simultaneity for all observers, while sr implies local. The presentist view on reality went down the drain at the same time because in a true presentist scenario everything that happen does it at the same instant in a. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity is an anthology of original essays by an.
We might have guessed incorrectly that if light is emitted simultaneously, then two observers halfway between the sources would see the flashes simultaneously. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity books. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity is an anthology of original essays by an international team of leading philosophers and physicists who, on the centenary of albert einstein s special theory of relativity, come together in this volume to reassess the contemporary paradigm of. Einstein, relativity, and absolute simultaneity ebook. I think this is a very important question because if simultaneity is absolute, then it shakes the foundation of relativity. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity ebook written by william lane craig, quentin smith. Toward a real synthesis of quantum and relativity theories. May 05, 2007 imagine two observers, one seated in the center of a speeding train car, and another standing on the platform as the train races by.
Shaffer, and stamatis vokos department of physics, university of washington, seattle, washington 981951560. Manual einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity ebook by. Lecture 3 and 4 relativity of simultaneity lorentzeinstein. One of the most fundamental deductions albert einstein made from the finite speed of light in his theory of special relativity is the relativity of simultaneity because light takes a finite time to traverse a distance in space, it is not possible to define simultaneity with respect to a universal clock shared by all observers. The relativity of simultaneity summary the weirdness. According to einstein s special theory of relativity, it is impossible to say in an absolute sense that two distinct events occur at the same time if those events are separated in space. The lorentzpoincares aetherbased interpretation of relativity is rare. It suggest that time dilation arises without length contraction, that sr is compatible with absolute simultaneity, and that the principle of reciprocity does not apply. The return of absolute simultaneity and its relationship to einsteins relativity of simultaneity espen gaarder haug. Pdf on einsteins relativity of simultaneity thought.
Absolute simultaneity the idea of absolute simultaneity was dismissed from science by the general acceptance of special relativity. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity 9780415591669. In einstein s theories, the ideas of absolute time and space were superseded by the notion of spacetime in special relativity, and curved spacetime in general relativity. Access this article in pdf format distance learning in einsteins fourth dimension. Simultaneity albert einstein and the theory of relativity. An analysis based on the properties of electromagnetic waves r. If deleuzes interpretation is correct, the beegson that duration and simultaneity develops is not one between bergson and einstein but a confrontation between bergsons interpretation of multiplicities and riemanns interpretation of multiplicity, riemanns interpretation bergsoh, according to deleuze, the basis of einstein s theory. Einstein s idea is to consider two lightnings, simultaneously falling at the trains extremities. We present a relativistic spacetime diagram that displays in true magnitudes the readings daytimes of two inertial reference frames clocks.
As mentioned above, in the present theory simultaneity is absolute, and the same is true. Illustrating the relativity of simultaneity and the thought experiments associated with it equations 12, and 14 leads to a relativistic spacetime diagram that enables us to find out the location of an event in k and the location of its einsteinlorentz transformed correspondent in k. Video created by stanford university for the course understanding einstein. In november 1915 albert einstein explained a radically new world view to the prussian academy of sciences with the general theory of relativity. A mathematical form of the relativity of simultaneity was introduced by hendrik lorentz and physically interpreted by henri poincare. Introduction in the late 1800s, the introduction of fast moving. He regarded the brain as an organ of choice, with a practical role. A great deal has changed since 1905 when einstein proposed his special theory of relativity, and this.
Norwegian university of life sciences may 4, 2016 abstract in this paper we show how einsteins relativity of simultaneity is fully consistent with anisotropic oneway speed of light. Einstein june 30, 1905 it is known that maxwells electrodynamicsas usually understood at the present timewhen applied to moving bodies, leads to asymmetries which do. If you set up an array of synchronised clocks over a volume of space and take a snapshot of all of them simultaneously, you will find that the one closest to you will appear to show a later time than the others, due to the time light needs to travel from each of the distant. I will suggest that, thanks to his knowledge of lorentzs 1895 versuch, einstein did know how to read them, and that it is quite possible that these observations first led einstein to the relativity of simultaneity. Box 1537, cresta 2118, gauteng, south aftica nonsimultaneity of two simultaneous events which occur at different positions within an inertial referenceframe passing by at a speed v. Special relativitysimultaneity, time dilation and length. Discovering the relativity of simultaneity how did einstein take the. Einstein s extension of the principle of relativity to all physical laws requires us to abandon galileos spacetimein particular, its universal planes of simultaneity that is, the notion of absolute time. On einsteins nonsimultaneity, lengthcontraction and time. Today it is generally believed that there is no reasonable alternative to einstein s interpretation of special relativity as well as to the minkowskis model of spacetime, which prohibit absolute simultaneity even in principle. The atheory of time has intuitive and metaphysical appeal, but suffers from tension, if not inconsistency, with the special and general theories of relativity str and gtr. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity by william.
This article blends the concepts of spacetime from theoretical physics and einstein s relativity theory to discuss the spatiotemporal nature of distance education. In physics, the relativity of simultaneity is the concept that distant simultaneity whether two spatially separated events occur at the same time is not absolute. With the help of the example of newtons sailor in the special theory of relativity we have. You dont have to share this achievement with either einstein or neinstein. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity is an anthology of original essays by an international team of leading philosophers and physicists who have come together to reassess the contemporary paradigm of the relativistic concept of time.
Relativity of simultaneity now suppose a, and at rest in s which is moving at speed v along xaxis. Their efforts provided a background for einstein s unique approach to understanding the universe, which he called in his native german a. An alternate lorentz transformation, absolute lorentz transformation alt, has similar kinematics to special relativity yet maintains absolute simultaneity in the context of a preferred reference frame. Brian 2004 some thoughts on relativity and the flow of time. The relativity of simultaneity adds to the repertoire of quantities that are relative and not absolute. One generally has the feeling that einstein s theory is. Lecture notes on special relativity macquarie university. Relativity of simultaneity explained absolute relativity. Neither does anyone say that yes, they believe simultaneity is absolute, nor does any expert give any convincing proof that it is relative. Consequences of special relativity boundless physics. Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity 2005 marked the centenary of one of the most remarkable publications in the history of science, albert einsteins on the electrodynamics of moving bodies, in which he presented a theory that later came to be known as the special theory of relativity. Duration and simultaneity bergson pdf henri bergson introduced new life to french philosophy, examining the nonmathematical sciences from a philosophical stance. In physics, the relativity of simultaneity is the concept that distant simultaneity whether two spatially separated events occur at the same time is not absolute, but depends on the observers reference frame.
Einstein, relativity and absolute simultaneity is an anthology of original essays by an international team of leading philosophers and physicists who, on the centenary of albert einstein s special theory of relativity, come together in this volume to reassess the contemporary paradigm of the relativistic concept of time. Pdf is the relativity of simultaneity a temporal illusion. One of the most dramatic consequences of einstein s theory of special relativity is the relativity of simultaneity, the fact that events perceived as simultaneous by one observer appear separated in time in a different frame of reference. An analysis based on the properties of electromagnetic waves. Bergson duration and simultaneity pdf henri bergson introduced new life to french philosophy, duration and simultaneity deals with one of the great bergsonian themes, time. Nov 16, 2011 is the atheory of time consistent with einstein s relativity of simultaneity. Wayne laboratory of natural philosophy, department of plant biology, cornell university, ithaca, ny, usa the determination of whether two distant events are simultaneous depends on the velocity of the observer. Implications of an absolute simultaneity theory for cosmology. The return of absolute simultaneity and its relationship. The atheory requires a notion of global simultaneity invariant under the symmetries of the worlds laws, those ostensible transformations of the state of the world that in fact leave the world as it was before. But an emission theory is precluded in special relativity by the. There is no such thing as simultaneity of distant events. Cosmological redshift can be interpreted as kinematic relativistic doppler.
Absolute distant simultaneity in special relativity hanoch benyami abstract. Chapters discuss einstein s special and general relativity, aspects and others experiments on the epr correlations, bohmdebroglie quantum physics, lorentzian interpretations of relativity, a means of defining absolute similtaneity in terms of a conservation principle for spacetime, the notion of absolute simultaneity in a universe with a. In the present work we have discussed the well known topic of simultaneous passing of photon through both the slit of young double slit experiment. Is the relativity of simultaneity a temporal illusion.
1428 390 156 1122 850 740 813 977 1361 118 100 685 578 169 1578 189 448 950 1561 958 1116 986 588 941 1432 395 4 1449 1476 282 926 1249 23 120